Know-how and collaborations without a contract: lessons from the Court of Bari

The case in brief

Contributing to the development of someone else's product is not enough to claim its know-how. In judgment no. 5270/2026 of 4 November 2026, the Specialised Business Division of the Court of Bari dismissed the claims of a company alleging misappropriation of its technical knowledge under Articles 98 and 99 of the Italian Industrial Property Code (IPC) and Article 2598(3) of the Italian Civil Code.

The company did, however, obtain payment for its work, approximately EUR 41,000, through an action for unjust enrichment (Article 2041 of the Civil Code). The outcome holds a useful lesson for anyone taking part in development projects without a written contract.

The facts

Four engineers devise a robot for cleaning and sifting sand on beaches. From 2010 to 2015 they rely on a metalworking company in Apulia, which provides its workshop, machinery and staff: fourteen prototypes are built.

No contract governs the collaboration. According to the company, the engineers had held out the prospect of a share in the product's future commercial success.

In the meantime, the engineers register the trademark (2011), file the patent application (2013) and set up a company, to which they contribute the patent and through which they market the robot. In 2016 the relationship breaks down: the company is offered only a component supply agreement, which it considers inadequate.

The company issues a pro forma invoice of approximately EUR 41,000 for the work performed and brings proceedings seeking an injunction, damages and publication of the judgment for infringement of its know-how. In the alternative, it seeks an order for unjust enrichment.

Why the know-how was not protected

The Court recalls the three requirements of Article 98 IPC: the information must be secret, have economic value because it is secret, and be subject to reasonable measures to keep it confidential (e.g. through access credentials, restrictions on the circulation of data, confidentiality agreements).

The decisive point, however, comes first: the company never identified which know-how had allegedly been taken from it. It did not describe the specific technical information, nor did it produce drawings, designs or documents embodying it. Without this, the court cannot verify secrecy and value, nor compare the claimant's knowledge with that used by the defendants.

Indeed, the witness evidence showed that the company's contribution was not merely material: feasibility checks, changes to the prototypes, functional tests, some CAD working drawings. The Court expressly acknowledges this. But a contribution, even an intellectual one, to engineering someone else's idea is not in itself a trade secret.

In short, protection does not extend to a mere idea, a generic solution to a technical problem, or purely executional input provided during prototyping. Once protection under Articles 98-99 IPC fails, so does the unfair competition claim under Article 2598(3) of the Civil Code, which rested on the same premise.

Whoever claims know-how must prove six things

The judgment expressly sets out the burden of proof on whoever invokes Articles 98 and 99 IPC:

  1. describe the features of the know-how in detail;

  2. identify each piece of information claimed to be secret;

  3. prove possession of it;

  4. demonstrate its economic value;

  5. document the measures taken to keep it confidential;

  6. prove its unlawful acquisition or use by the other party.

The body of knowledge must have taken concrete form in designs, drawings, procedures, instructions or data. These documents may be filed in court using methods that preserve their confidentiality.

Recovery through unjust enrichment

Having dismissed the main claim, the Court upheld the alternative claim under Article 2041 of the Civil Code, but only against the company that markets the robot. That company was ordered to pay EUR 41,113.41 including VAT, plus statutory interest from the date of judgment until payment.

The key issue was the subsidiary nature of the action, which is available only where the injured party has no other remedy. The Court held this requirement satisfied because the contractual relationship existed with the four engineers, not with the company, which was set up only later. The fact that neither the work nor its amount was disputed also carried weight.

What to do in practice

The case is a typical one: an SME puts its expertise and workshop at the service of designers or a start-up, without a contract, counting on a future return. When the relationship breaks down, recovering the value of its contribution becomes difficult. Some practical guidance follows.

If you contribute to the development of someone else's product:

  • formalise the relationship before starting: scope, consideration, any share of revenue or royalties;

  • regulate ownership of the results, including improvements, working drawings and engineering solutions;

  • have an NDA signed that identifies the confidential information you are making available;

  • keep a written record of your technical contribution: drawings, test reports, changes, emails;

  • invoice your work regularly, without waiting for the project to end.

If your company wants to protect its know-how:

  • map and describe in writing the information you consider secret;

  • adopt concrete, documentable measures: restricted access, document classification, confidentiality clauses with employees and partners;

  • keep the documentation in a form that can be filed in court.

If you commission the development:

  • regulate by contract the ownership of what the supplier produces;

  • pay for the work received: as this judgment shows, even without a contract the risk of an order under Article 2041 of the Civil Code remains real.

Next
Next

Thrilling trademarks: Monsterland vs. Horrorland