By an order of 22 October 2026, issued in proceedings UPC_CFI_2221/2026, brought by Sandoz AG against Novo Nordisk A/S concerning Unitary Patent EP 3 689 365, the Milan Central Division of the Unified Patent Court (UPC), ruling on a preliminary objection to jurisdiction, addressed the use of divisional applications by a patent proprietor seeking to avoid a decision on the validity of its patent while retaining substantially equivalent protection through new applications within the same patent family.
The Court held that its jurisdiction, although confined to the matters listed in Article 32 of the Agreement on a Unified Patent Court (UPCA), encompasses the powers necessary to ensure effective judicial protection, including against the abusive use of divisional applications.
Divisional application
A divisional application is a new European patent application that derives from an earlier application that is still pending (the so-called parent application) and reproduces all or part of its content. Under Article 76(1) of the European Patent Convention (EPC), it may only relate to subject-matter already contained in the parent application as filed; in that case, it retains the filing date and any priority of the parent application.
The mechanism serves an ordinary, legitimate function. It allows, for example, distinct inventions to be separated where the European Patent Office (EPO) finds a lack of unity of invention, or different aspects of the same disclosure to be examined separately.
Divisional game
The expression divisional game refers to the potentially abusive use of divisional applications to keep alive protection that is at risk of being declared invalid in court proceedings.
In short, the pattern is as follows. The proprietor of a patent challenged in court keeps pending a divisional application in the same family, with claims of similar content. As the decision on validity approaches, the proprietor brings the patent to an end, for example by withdrawing approval of the text under Article 113(2) EPC. The revocation action thus risks becoming devoid of purpose, while the same subject-matter continues to be pursued through the divisional application, which may later be granted and enforced.
For competitors, this results in prolonged uncertainty: even when the original patent ceases to exist, market entry remains exposed to new patent rights with a substantially identical scope of protection.
The UPC's ruling
In the case at hand, Sandoz had sought revocation of the patent and, in order to prevent the divisional game, three further measures: a declaration of obviousness of the composition covered by the patent, not limited to the validity of the latter; an Arrow-type declaration of lack of inventive step of equivalent claims of patents in the same family; and a provisional order preventing the defendant from withdrawing its approval of the text of the patent before the EPO. The defendant objected that the UPC lacked jurisdiction over these three requests.
The Court first made clear that filing divisional applications is legitimate and, in the specific case, did not find sufficient evidence to establish an abuse. It observed, however, that using divisional applications to shield the patent from judicial scrutiny, while maintaining its exclusionary effect, could amount to an abuse of rights: the right to file divisional applications serves to organise the protection of the disclosed subject-matter, not to evade the decision on validity.
As to the UPC's powers, the Court reiterated that its jurisdiction remains delimited by Article 32 UPCA. This would not mean, however, that its powers are limited to the measures and remedies expressly provided for in the Agreement. A court vested with exclusive jurisdiction to decide on the validity of patents should indeed also have the procedural tools needed to preserve the integrity and effectiveness of the proceedings before it. This would not be an additional jurisdiction beyond that conferred by the UPCA, but powers implicit in it, to the extent that they serve to secure its actual exercise.
One of the tools identified is Rule 360 of the Rules of Procedure (RoP)[1], which allows the Court to dispose of an action that has become devoid of purpose. According to the Court, withdrawal of the patent would not automatically lead to the action being disposed of: it must be ascertained whether the claimant retains a concrete interest in a decision. Should it emerge that the withdrawal serves an abusive strategy of continuing protection through a divisional application, the Court could continue the proceedings and rule on the validity of the withdrawn patent.
Such a ruling would not directly concern the divisional application, the grant of which remains a matter for the EPO. It would, however, be relevant in subsequent infringement or revocation proceedings concerning the divisional application, to the extent that its claims substantially correspond to the subject-matter already adjudicated. It will be for the court hearing those proceedings to verify this, without any automatic effect.
On that basis, the Court dismissed the defendant's objection as regards the declaration concerning patents in the same family and the order not to withdraw approval of the text, affirming its jurisdiction but deferring to the main proceedings the assessment of final admissibility and of the conditions for granting the relief sought. By contrast, it declared manifestly inadmissible the request for a general declaration of obviousness of the composition, as it was framed in abstract terms, without reference to a specific patent or product.
[1] Rule 360. RoP: “If the Court finds that an action has become devoid of purpose and that there is no longer any need to adjudicate on it, it may at any time, on the application of a party or of its own motion, after giving the parties an opportunity to be heard, dispose of the action by way of order”.